Friday, November 20, 2009
Alliance
You are here Articles
   

 Share this article online:

 

Share

Wartburg administration react to Project Orange

Last Updated Mar 27, 2009


JACKIE ALBRECHT NEWS EDITOR

 

Members of Wartburg’s administration are uncertain whether Wednesday’s Project Orange movement was the best way for students to voice their concerns. 

Dean of Faculty Ferol Menzel heard about Project Orange Tuesday afternoon and communicated her concerns to Student Body President Travis Bockenstedt.  Menzel said she was worried about students taking a day off this late in the semester.

“I would have preferred not recommending students to not go to classes.  I think there are probably other ways it could’ve been accomplished,” Menzel said. 

Interim President William Hamm said although he suspects Project Orange was effective to get students’ messages out, he is unsure whether the movement was the best way for students to build trust. 

“I suppose in due course we’ll see how that all works,” Hamm said.

Hamm said he is sympathetic with student concerns as are his colleagues. 

“I don’t get up in the morning thinking us versus them, and I never have,” Hamm said.

Menzel and Hamm both said they were unclear about the student issues listed in a memorandum sent by Student Senate to faculty Wednesday.   

“I’m eagerly awaiting some sort of organized effort to talk about the issues that were outlined in the document,” Menzel said. 

“Student grievances are not carefully defined at this point,” Hamm said.

The two administrators said they are unclear about how an Outfly and student concerns are linked together. 

“I had no knowledge of the grievances when 1,000 students showed up on my doorstep at 6:30. …  I mean the students knew, but I didn’t.  Nobody ever told me that there were grievances that this day was about,” Hamm said.

Menzel sent an e-mail to faculty Wednesday morning telling them it was not an authorized day off for students and that faculty needed to respond to absences consistent to what is listed in their syllabi. The administration chose not to send an e-mail to the student body.

“My assumption is that faculty all have their students on my.wartburg that it would just be easier for them to communicate with students and let them know what was going on,” Menzel said. 

Both Hamm and Menzel addressed some of the student concerns.

Hamm said he understands that tuition is too high, but every student in America on every campus believes this. 

The Student Senate executive team and Hamm have been talking about “The W” locker rooms for a year, he said. 

“That thing is blown all out of proportion as a key issue in my mind,” Hamm said.  “But obviously it is something that is more important to people than about anything else.” 

Menzel said faculty evaluations and faculty workload are issues currently being discussed in various Faculty Senate committees.

“We are actually talking about the student ratings of instruction (SRIs) right now and the possibility of improving the form and the process. So that’s an ongoing conversation,” Menzel said.

Despite being unsure about the method in which students chose to voice their concerns, Hamm commented on the number of people in the crowd at his house Wednesday morning.

“We always say our school spirit at Wartburg is better than other places.  I thought it was pretty impressive [Wednesday morning],” he said.

Menzel said it was good to see students caring about something because there will be times in students’ lives when they need to take a stand.

Menzel also said she hoped students receive feedback on Project Orange and are able to learn something from this. 

“I have no idea whether the campus will be supportive or not supportive, I think it will be interesting to see as people reflect on what happened whether it is going to be effective or not so effective,” she said. 
 

Rate this:
Recent Comments
It sounds as though Dean Menzel's hopes for a dialogue correspond to ours, and I intend to see that we achieve them. To those that point out "dialogues" were already ongoing, I would refer them to the discussion of locker rooms in the W that have been occurring since its construction---and ask them to show me the effectiveness of these discussions in view of the fact that there are STILL no shower curtains in the student showers. Honestly, if we're going to have segregated locker rooms, they should be close to equal...or at least be actually functional.
Posted By: OutflyKnight 1 on Mar 27, 2009
Many students I have spoken with had no idea there were "grievances" - they thought it was just a call for Outfly. They signed a petition and/or marched to Greenwood with no idea that they were "supporting" a cause. This was an unethical way to garner student support.
Posted By: Concerned W on Mar 27, 2009
If they managed to make it all the way to Greenwood without listening to either speech, without noticing 600 issue-inscribed flags carried by the students, and without hearing the calls to action during the march itself--much less if they willingly signed a petition about which they had no idea as to the reason--then you're right, we DO have a big problem. Better not let those people walk outside when it's raining, they might look up and drown.
Posted By: OutflyKnight 1 on Mar 27, 2009
1. Why would any student sign a document without reading the information attached specifically explaining topics of interest? 2. Didn't an e-mail from Student Senate go out specifically outlining the grievances earlier in the week? 3. Didn't the student body president give a speech addressing concerns before the students marched to the President's? If students didn't know about the issues they were marching for then it isn't because the information wasn't there. If that's the case they made an uninformed decision and that is no ones fault but their own.
Posted By: Senior S on Mar 27, 2009
Despite the negative reaction Project Orange has received from administrators, faculty, staff, alum , and students alike, what has been lost in this is that the body of the college, the students, managed to gather together to fight for what they believe in. As a professor of mine rightly pointed out Wednesday, the students used their liberal arts education, why should we stop them? If the college sets out to teach us to become leaders in service as a "spirited" expression of our faith and learning, what better way then to rally together in the manner we did as an extension of the teachings of Martin Luther? We as students do forget that this institution is indeed a business. We are not without guilt. However, administrators appear to forget that not only is this a school, a place of learning, but it is also our home. We physically live here. If those in charge lived in the conditions we often do, they would be immediately repairing their homes. We do have it good comparatively, but is there a real reason student have to live in study rooms, why the residents of the Manors have to put up with flooding, why residents of the Complex and Clinton have to deal with rainwater dripping into their rooms, why Founders is slowly sinking into the ground? And why aren't all of our dorms handicap accessible? We pride ourselves on welcoming all people yet don't provide safe places for them to live? We are blessed with an intensely strong faculty who strive for excellence in our academics and in our lives. Yet it is the few less stellar who give those deserving professors a poor reputation. The students have been voicing their concerns over their faculty, they haven't been listened to. Who would know better how effective a teacher is than the student? And on another note, Dean Menzel, no disrespect meant towards her as I have not yet met her, but the email she sent to the faculty was that they "Outfly" was not approved by the Dean's Office. Unfortunately she fails to specify the fact that it did not have approval from the Dean of Faculty's Office. What about the other Dean's? By speaking on behalf of all of them without regard to their true belief's on the matter, is nothing but disrespectful to the Dean's as individuals, but also to the students of whom they represent.
Posted By: ProudKnight 1 on Mar 27, 2009
If the administration were unaware of the issues students were campaigning for prior to Wednesday, it means one of two things. Administration is either unapproachable or not present in student’s lives OR Administration has their eyes closed and ears plugged. If Administration would take 2 minutes to talk to students, they could see that these issues are very much so a reality.
Posted By: peacemarcher w on Mar 29, 2009
Ferrell Menzel has known about these some of these issues for *years.* Being an alum who was there when she was hired and witnessed her crack down and fire some beloved faculty, I can tell you that she has little concern for student, parent or alum input. Unless, that is, you're an alum with loads of cash you'd like to throw at the school. She is a cold, callused, uncaring administrator. Her responses prove it. She suggested another way? Students have been trying to get her attention for over 10 years. Nothing works for her. If it's not by the book, she's not for it. If it's not her way, it's no way. The president, by the way, really is a figure head. That lady is the one who runs that school. She's Wartburg's very own Dick Cheney.
Posted By: pevedalum 1 on Mar 30, 2009
The Courtroom
Tags Minimize
  1. 26 items are tagged with women's
  2. 22 items are tagged with men's
  3. 22 items are tagged with win
  4. 20 items are tagged with Basketball
  5. 18 items are tagged with lose
  6. 17 items are tagged with Soccer
  7. 14 items are tagged with Service
  8. 13 items are tagged with Outfly
  9. 13 items are tagged with Wartburg
  10. 13 items are tagged with Waverly
  11. 12 items are tagged with President
  12. 12 items are tagged with student senate
  13. 11 items are tagged with Football
  14. 11 items are tagged with students
  15. 9 items are tagged with Loras
  16. 9 items are tagged with Simpson
  17. 9 items are tagged with Tennis
  18. 9 items are tagged with track
  19. 8 items are tagged with H1N1
  20. 8 items are tagged with Project Orange
  21. 8 items are tagged with sustainability
  22. 8 items are tagged with Volleyball
  23. 7 items are tagged with Library
  24. 7 items are tagged with Softball
  25. 7 items are tagged with Wrestling
  26. 6 items are tagged with Buena Vista
  27. 6 items are tagged with Facebook
  28. 6 items are tagged with flu
  29. 6 items are tagged with IIAC
  30. 6 items are tagged with Knights
  31. 6 items are tagged with Luther
  32. 6 items are tagged with sports
  33. 6 items are tagged with winter
  34. 5 items are tagged with Baseball
  35. 5 items are tagged with Coe
  36. 5 items are tagged with Cross Country
  37. 5 items are tagged with energy
  38. 5 items are tagged with faculty
  39. 5 items are tagged with Germany
  40. 5 items are tagged with housing
  41. 5 items are tagged with Obama
  42. 5 items are tagged with senate
  43. 5 items are tagged with technology
  44. 4 items are tagged with Alliance
  45. 4 items are tagged with athletics
  46. 4 items are tagged with awareness
  47. 4 items are tagged with Colson
  48. 4 items are tagged with Dubuque
  49. 4 items are tagged with environment
  50. 4 items are tagged with freshmen

 

Privacy StatementTerms Of UseCopyright 2009 The Wartburg College Circuit